Self-Rating Is Irrelevant I

Relieving the burden of constant self-judgment

Welcome to this week’s Pebbles in the Pond Blog, written by Bill Harvey
November 20, 2026

MIND MAGIC/MIND EXPERIMENTS: The 50th Anniversary Edition Excerpt Series: Part 16Nothing is either good or bad...All that exists simply is.We are conditioned to rate ourselves.
At any given moment, our self-rating programs communicate one of two possible messages: “(Our name) good boy/girl” or “(Our name) bad boy/girl.”

These messages are also emphasized to varying degrees. All other self-evaluative statements can be reduced to one of these two basic types.

This self-rating program is another internalized voice that originally belonged to other individuals who used it as a reward-and-punishment device to condition us to perform the way they wanted. When we did what they wanted, they said “(Our name) good boy/girl”; when we didn’t, they said “(Our name) bad boy/girl.”

This program now has independent life in our minds. In effect, we say to ourselves, “(Our name) good boy/girl” at every moment it seems justified, because it brings us happiness; and when robbed of this opportunity, we grouse, “(Our name) bad boy/girl.”

Our happiness and self-approval should depend on the awareness that we are doing our best, not on events that are only partially under our control. Therefore, we should stop rating ourselves and get the job done.

Rating ourselves is irrelevant because all ratings are ascribed; they have no independent, objective reality.
Nothing is either good or bad; an observer ascribes goodness or badness. All that exists simply is. Goodness or badness is a function of the observer and exists only in the observer as observer.

All self-rating is an implicit identification with the current window through which we are looking, i.e., with our current robot.

We often feel we must place ourselves on a different level from all other individuals, either higher or lower. This is to reinforce our feelings of being special and unique.

Therefore, when rating ourselves, we identify with our current vehicle rather than the universe.

Once we embark on this path, we will begin to set up our own ambushes. Regarding these ambushes with patience and good humor, we will identify and conquer them; seeking to club them out of our way is merely another ambush.

One example of an ambush: we may begin to implicitly ask ourselves constantly, “Am I doing it right now? How about now? And now?” or “Am I happy now? How about now? And now?” This type of ambush guarantees misery through overzealous coveting of its opposite. It leads to periods of euphoria when we suppose we are doing everything right, followed by sudden depression when the streak seems to break.

Keeping score is pointless; we simply meet each new moment as best we can, regardless of what has just transpired. Likewise, trying to remember all suggestions is ineffective; we only need to remember what seems applicable at any given moment.

Instead of constantly rating our success, we choose to answer the voices in our heads that ask how well we are doing at any given moment by saying: “I am doing as I am doing. You may judge it good or bad as you desire; it is not my judgment.”

Mind Experiments

1. De-charging approval circuits
Remember all the people whose approval was ever important to you.

Relive the moments of their greatest approval (when they hooked you) and their most traumatic disapproval.

Keep reliving these until they become utterly boring.

2. Taking goodness and badness out of objects
Next time you find yourself confronting an object you say is either very good or very bad, still the voices in your head and sense the object directly, without the “good” or “bad” haze.

What did you learn about it that you didn’t know before?

3. Identifying with the universe
For one day, stay conscious of what’s going on inside your robot, outside your robot, and out of your robot’s sight—as all being you.

Our best wishes to all,
THEI Team

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *